
June 9, 1954
"Have You No Sense of Decency?"
Wisconsin Republican Senator Joseph R. McCarthy rocketed to public attention in 1950 with his allegations that hundreds of Communists had infiltrated the State Department and other federal agencies. These charges struck a particularly responsive note at a time of deepening national anxiety about the spread of world communism.
McCarthy relentlessly continued his anticommunist campaign into 1953, when he gained a new platform as chairman of the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations. He quickly put his imprint on that subcommittee, shifting its focus from investigating fraud and waste in the executive branch to hunting for Communists. He conducted scores of hearings, calling hundreds of witnesses in both public and closed sessions.
A dispute over his hiring of staff without consulting other committee members prompted the panel's three Democrats to resign in mid 1953. Republican senators also stopped attending, in part because so many of the hearings were called on short notice or held away from the nation's capital. As a result, McCarthy and his chief counsel Roy Cohn largely ran the show by themselves, relentlessly grilling and insulting witnesses. Harvard law dean Ervin Griswold described McCarthy's role as "judge, jury, prosecutor, castigator, and press agent, all in one."
In the spring of 1954, McCarthy picked a fight with the U.S. Army, charging lax security at a top-secret army facility. The army responded that the senator had sought preferential treatment for a recently drafted subcommittee aide. Amidst this controversy, McCarthy temporarily stepped down as chairman for the duration of the three-month nationally televised spectacle known to history as the Army-McCarthy hearings.
The army hired Boston lawyer Joseph Welch to make its case. At a session on June 9, 1954, McCarthy charged that one of Welch's attorneys had ties to a Communist organization. As an amazed television audience looked on, Welch responded with the immortal lines that ultimately ended McCarthy's career: "Until this moment, Senator, I think I never really gauged your cruelty or your recklessness." When McCarthy tried to continue his attack, Welch angrily interrupted, "Let us not assassinate this lad further, senator. You have done enough. Have you no sense of decency?"
Overnight, McCarthy's immense national popularity evaporated. Censured by his Senate colleagues, ostracized by his party, and ignored by the press, McCarthy died three years later, 48 years old and a broken man.
********
Hollywood Blacklist.... (I hope that this scares the hell out of us because history repeats itself and it feels very close to me about now.. not the Hollywood part but the "fear factor" part.)
The Red Channels list
- Larry Adler, actor and musician
- Luther Adler, actor and director
- Stella Adler, actress and teacher
- Edith Atwater, actress
- Howard Bay, scenic designer
- Ralph Bell, actor
- Leonard Bernstein, composer and conductor
- Walter Bernstein, screenwriter
- Michael Blankfort, screenwriter1
- Marc Blitzstein, composer
- True Boardman, screenwriter
- Millen Brand, writer
- Oscar Brand, folk singer
- Joseph Edward Bromberg, actor
- Himan Brown, producer and director
- John Brown, actor
- Abe Burrows, playwright and lyricist
- Morris Carnovsky, actor
- Vera Caspary, writer
- Edward Chodorov, screenwriter and producer
- Jerome Chodorov, writer
- Mady Christians, actress
- Lee J. Cobb, actor
- Marc Connelly, playwright
- Aaron Copland, composer
- Norman Corwin, writer
- Howard Da Silva, actor
- Roger De Koven, actor
- Dean Dixon, conductor
- Olin Downes, music critic
- Alfred Drake, actor
- Paul Draper, actor and dancer
- Howard Duff, actor
- Clifford J. Durr, attorney
- Richard Dyer-Bennett, folk singer
- José Ferrer, actor
- Louise Fitch (Lewis), actress
- Martin Gabel, actor
- Arthur Gaeth, radio commentator
- William S. Gailmor, journalist and radio commentator
- John Garfield, actor
- Will Geer, actor
- Jack Gilford, actor
- Tom Glazer, folk singer
- Ruth Gordon, actress and screenwriter
- Lloyd Gough, actor
- Morton Gould, pianist and composer
- Shirley Graham, writer
- Ben Grauer, radio and TV personality
- Mitchell Grayson, radio producer and director
|
- Horace Grenell, conductor and music producer
- Uta Hagen, actress and teacher
- Dashiell Hammett, writer
- E. Y. "Yip" Harburg, lyricist
- Robert P. Heller, television journalist
- Lillian Hellman, playwright and screenwriter
- Nat Hiken, writer and producer
- Rose Hobart, actress
- Judy Holliday, actress
- Roderick B. Holmgren, journalist
- Lena Horne, singer and actress
- Langston Hughes, writer
- Marsha Hunt, actress
- Leo Hurwitz, director
- Charles Irving, actor
- Burl Ives, folk singer and actor
- Sam Jaffe, actor
- Leon Janney, actor
- Joseph Julian, actor
- Garson Kanin, writer and director
- George Keane, actor
- Donna Keath, radio actress
- Pert Kelton, actress
- Alexander Kendrick, journalist and author
- Adelaide Klein, actress
- Felix Knight, singer and actor
- Howard Koch, screenwriter
- Tony Kraber, actor
- Millard Lampell, screenwriter
- John La Touche, lyricist
- Arthur Laurents, writer
- Gypsy Rose Lee, actress and ecdysiast
- Madeline Lee, actress2
- Ray Lev, classical pianist
- Philip Loeb, actor
- Ella Logan, actress and singer
- Alan Lomax, folklorist and musicologist
- Avon Long, actor and singer
- Joseph Losey, director
- Peter Lyon, television writer
- Aline MacMahon, actress
- Paul Mann, director and teacher
- Margo, actress and dancer
- Myron McCormick, actor
- Paul McGrath, radio actor
- Burgess Meredith, actor
- Arthur Miller, playwright
- Henry Morgan, radio and TV comedian
- Zero Mostel, actor
- Jean Muir, actress
- Meg Mundy, actress
- Lyn Murray, composer and choral director
|
- Ben Myers, attorney
- Dorothy Parker, writer
- Arnold Perl, producer and writer
- Minerva Pious, actress
- Samson Raphaelson, screenwriter and playwright
- Bernard Reis, accountant
- Anne Revere, actress
- Kenneth Roberts, writer
- Earl Robinson, composer and lyricist
- Edward G. Robinson, actor
- William N. Robson, radio and TV writer
- Harold Rome, composer and lyricist
- Norman Rosten, writer
- Selena Royle, actress
- Coby Ruskin, TV director
- Robert St. John, journalist
- Hazel Scott, jazz and classical musician
- Pete Seeger, folk singer
- Lisa Sergio, radio personality
- Artie Shaw, jazz musician
- Irwin Shaw, writer
- Robert Louis Shayon, former president of radio and TV directors' guild
- Ann Shepherd, actress
- William L. Shirer, journalist
- Allan Sloane, radio and TV writer
- Howard K. Smith, journalist
- Gale Sondergaard, actress
- Hester Sondergaard, actress
- Lionel Stander, actor
- Johannes Steel, journalist
- Paul Stewart, actor
- Elliott Sullivan, actor
- William Sweets, radio personality
- Helen Tamiris, choreographer
- Betty Todd, director
- Louis Untermeyer, poet
- Hilda Vaughn, actress
- J. Raymond Walsh, radio commentator
- Sam Wanamaker, actor
- Theodore Ward, playwright
- Fredi Washington, actress
- Margaret Webster, actress, director and producer
- Orson Welles, actor, writer and director
- Josh White, blues musician
- Irene Wicker, singer and actress
- Betty Winkler (Keane), actress
- Martin Wolfson, actor
- Lesley Woods, actress
- Richard Yaffe, journalist
|
Note 1: Michael Blankfort gave cooperative, if uninformative, testimony to HUAC and was not blacklisted (see Navasky 1980: 101–102). Note 2: Madeline Lee—who was married to actor Jack Gilford, also listed by Red Channels—was frequently confused with another actress of the era named Madaline Lee.
Other persons first blacklisted after June 1950
- Eddie Albert, actor (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 188)
- Nelson Algren, writer (Hazucha 2002: 49)
- Lew Amster, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 28)
- Richard Attenborough, director and producer (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 253)
- Norma Barzman, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 159)
- Sol Barzman, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 146)
- Orson Bean, actor (Faulk 1963: 7)
- Albert Bein, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 28)
- Barbara Bel Geddes, actress (Katz 1994: 106)
- Ben Bengal, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 50)
- Seymour Bennett, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 123)
- Leonardo Bercovici, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 21)
- Herschel Bernardi, actor (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 42)
- John Berry, actor, screenwriter and director (Denning 1998: 374; Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 108)
- Henry Blankfort, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 31)
- Laurie Blankfort, artist (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 31)
- Roman Bohnen, actor (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 49)
- Allen Boretz, screenwriter and songwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 83)
- Phoebe Brand, actress (Schwartz, J. 1999; Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 50)
- John Bright, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 2)
- Phil Brown, actor (Barzman 2004: 449)
- Harold Buchman, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 22)
- Sidney Buchman, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 128)
- Luis Buñuel, director (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 6)
- Val Burton, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 17)
- Hugo Butler, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 22)
- Alan Campbell, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 129)
- Charles Chaplin, actor, director and producer (Katz 1994: 241)
- Maurice Clark, screenwriter (Navasky 1980: 283)
- Richard Collins, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 73)
- Charles Collingwood, radio commentator (Faulk 1963: 7–8)
- Dorothy Comingore, actress (Denning 1998: 374; Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 20)
- Jeff Corey, actor (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 77)
- George Corey, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 151)
- John Cromwell, director (Lumenick 2007a)
- Charles Dagget, animator (Cohen 2004: 178)
- Jules Dassin, director (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 105)
- Karen DeWolf, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 5)
- Howard Dimsdale, writer (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 250)
- Ludwig Donath, actor (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 49)
- Arnaud d'Usseau, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 83)
- Phil Eastman, cartoon writer (Cohen 2004: 178)
- Leslie Edgley, screenwriter (Navasky 1980: 282)
- Edward Eliscu, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 7)
- Faith Elliott, animator (Barzman 2004: 89)
- Cy Endfield, screenwriter and director (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 137)
- Guy Endore, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 83)
- Francis Edward Faragoh, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 14)
- Howard Fast, writer (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 48)
- John Henry Faulk, radio personality (Faulk 1963: 6–7)
- Jerry Fielding, composer (Burlingame 2000: 74)
- Carl Foreman, producer and screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: xi)
- Anne Froelick, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 250)
- Lester Fuller, director (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 251)
- Bert Gilden, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 105)
- Lee Gold, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 139)
- Harold Goldman, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 16)
- Michael Gordon, director (Dick 1982: 80)
- Jay Gorney, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 96)
- Lee Grant, actress (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 31)
- Morton Grant, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 13)
- Anne Green, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 95)
- Jack T. Gross, producer (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 37)
- Margaret Gruen, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 164)
- Tamara Hovey, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 15)
- John Hubley, animator (Cohen 2004: 178)
- Edward Huebsch, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 18)
- Ian McLellan Hunter, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 86)
- Kim Hunter, actress (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: viii)
- John Ireland, actor (Doherty 2003: 236)
- Daniel James, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 80)
- Paul Jarrico, producer and screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 134)
- Sidney Kingsley, playwright
- Gordon Kahn, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 250)
- Victor Kilian, actor (Graulich and Tatum 2003: 115)
- Alexander Knox, actor (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 194)
|
- Mickey Knox, actor (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 106)
- Lester Koenig, producer (Herman 1997: 356)
- Charles Korvin, actor (Korvin 1997)
- Hy Kraft, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 39)
- Millard Lampell, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 51)
- Constance Lee, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 24)
- Robert Lees, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 86)
- Carl Lerner, editor and director (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 150)
- Irving Lerner, director (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 53)
- Lewis Leverett, actor (Schwartz 1999)
- Alfred Lewis Levitt, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 130)
- Helen Slote Levitt, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 130)
- Mitch Lindemann, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 37)
- Norman Lloyd, actor (Denning 1998: 374; Lumenick 2007b)
- Ben Maddow, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 110)
- Arnold Manoff, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 20)
- Robert A. McGowan, screenwriter and director
- John McGrew, animator (Cohen 2004: 178)
- Ruth McKenney, writer (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 142)
- Bill Melendez, animator (Cohen 2004: 178)
- John "Skins" Miller, actor (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 8)
- Paula Miller, actress (Schwartz 1999)
- Josef Mischel, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 110)
- Karen Morley, actress (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 78)
- Henry Myers, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 26)
- Mortimer Offner, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 7)
- Alfred Palca, producer (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 157)
- Larry Parks, actor (Navasky 1980: 371–373)
- Leo Penn, actor (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 45)
- Irving Pichel, director (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 10)
- Louis Pollock, screenwriter (Ceplair and Englund 2003: 388)
- Abraham Polonsky, screenwriter and director (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 13)
- Vladimir Pozner, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 11)
- Stanley Prager, director (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 15)
- John Randolph, actor (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 247)
- Maurice Rapf, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 163)
- Rosaura Revueltas, actress (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 253)
- Robert L. Richards, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 80)
- Frederic I. Rinaldo, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 1)
- Martin Ritt, actor and director (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 18)
- W. L. River, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 5)
- Marguerite Roberts, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 88)
- Louise Rousseau, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 6)
- Jean Rouverol (Butler), actress and writer (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 142)
- Shimen Ruskin, actor (Navasky 1980: 282)
- Madeleine Ruthven, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 55)
- Waldo Salt, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 208)
- John Sandford, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 101)
- Bill Scott, voice actor (Cohen 2004: 178)
- Martha Scott, actress (Ceplair and Englund 2003: 388)
- Joshua Shelley, actor (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 45)
- Reuben Ship, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 218)
- Viola Brothers Shore, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 11)
- George Sklar, playwright (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 6)
- Art Smith, actor (Schwartz, J. 1999)
- Louis Solomon, screenwriter and producer (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 63)
- Ray Spencer, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 37)
- Janet Stevenson, writer (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 49)
- Philip Stevenson, writer (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 49)
- Donald Ogden Stewart, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 36)
- Arthur Strawn, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 91)
- Bess Taffel, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 15)
- Julius Tannenbaum, producer (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 22)
- Frank Tarloff, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 175)
- Shepard Traube, director and screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 17)
- Dorothy Tree, actress (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 47)
- Paul Trivers, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 141)
- George Tyne, actor (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 45)
- Michael Uris, writer (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 90)
- Peter Viertel, screenwriter (Navasky 1980: 93–94)
- Bernard Vorhaus, director (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 9)
- John Weber, producer (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 209)
- Richard Weil, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 18)
- Hannah Weinstein, producer (Buhle and Wagner 2003b: 66)
- John Wexley, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 111)
- Michael Wilson, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: vii)
- Richard N. Wright, writer (Hazucha 2002: 49)
- Nedrick Young, actor and screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 248)
- Julian Zimet, screenwriter (Buhle and Wagner 2003a: 83)
|
Hi: I am in possession of a Sterling Silver Bracelet with a skull and crossbones on the front and inscribed with '47 on botton and BLACK LIST on the top. On the back it has the initials B.J.S. to B.H. Upon reviewing your list I believe the intials may stand for William "Bill" John Scott and Robert "Bob" Heller. What do you think?
Reply to this
Joe, I have no idea but I am certainly curious! I would love to know how you acquired the bracelet and if you take it to an expert to be evaluated please let us know the results! Thank you.
Reply to this
Hello again: I picked it up at a flea market in the San Francisco Bay Area. I guess I could "attribute" it to the Blacklist...Joe
Reply to this
It's a good provenance for it that is for sure! I hope that you stumble into its exact origins. It's so interesting.
Reply to this
Thats great information i really like it. thanks for this useful information.
Reply to this